Incident location, Long Island
What Happened
Four of the deadliest roads in New York state are located on Long Island, according to a new five-year study by I-Select that analyzed fatal crashes across the state. The study found that Long Island accounts for four of the state’s top 10 deadliest roads, with local highways claiming spots throughout the rankings.
The Long Island Expressway (I-495) tops the list locally and ranks third deadliest statewide, with 42 fatal crashes during the five-year period analyzed by I-Select. Drivers say excessive speed is a major concern on the expressway. “You go 75 on the expressway and you have to be in the slow lane because everyone is going by at 85,” said Frank Saladino, of Selden.
Sunrise Highway (SR-27) also made the top 10, ranking fifth statewide with 36 fatal crashes during the same period. The Southern State Parkway (SR-908M) followed closely behind, coming in seventh with 32 fatal crashes over the five years studied.
Middle Country Road (SR-25) ranks as the 10th deadliest roadway in New York, with 24 fatal crashes along the corridor over the five-year period. Edwin Nunez, who has lived near the roadway in Selden for about a decade, says the ranking reflects what he sees every day. “That does not surprise me at all. I do see a little more regarding accidents happening around because people are not cautious, but traffic is building up around the area,” Nunez said.
Transportation and planning advocates say the problem has intensified in recent years. Elissa Kyle, placemaking director with Vision Long Island, points to behavioral and vehicle changes since the pandemic. “People are driving more aggressively since COVID, we’ve noticed. Vehicles have changed to some extent, and they are getting larger and larger,” Kyle said.
The complete I-Select ranking shows I-87 as the deadliest road statewide with 58 total crashes, followed by US-9 with 44 crashes. Other roads in the top 10 include I-90 with 36 crashes, US-9W with 34 crashes, US-11 with 31 crashes, and SR-104 with 26 crashes.
Location & Road Context
The four Long Island roads span major transportation corridors across Nassau and Suffolk counties. The Long Island Expressway serves as the primary east-west highway through the island, while Sunrise Highway provides an alternative southern route. The Southern State Parkway connects western Long Island communities, and Middle Country Road runs through central Suffolk County communities including Selden and Calverton.
The New York State Department of Transportation says it has already made several improvements along Middle Country Road, including new turning lanes in Calverton, and that additional upgrades are planned. In a statement, the Department of Transportation says it encourages all motorists to observe posted speed limits, avoid aggressive driving and follow all traffic laws.
Broader Impact
Kyle from Vision Long Island adds that increased awareness and caution remain some of the best tools drivers have when traveling on Long Island’s most dangerous roads, as infrastructure improvements alone cannot address the behavioral changes observed since the pandemic.