Incident location, Long Island
What Happened
Ganesh Shenoy was sentenced to 3.5-10 years in prison Friday for killing Philip Mastropolo in a deadly high-speed crash in Hicksville 20 years ago, after fleeing to India and evading justice for two decades. The sentencing took place more than 20 years after the April 2005 crash that claimed the life of the 44-year-old father of three at the intersection of Levittown Parkway and Old Country Road.
Prosecutors say Shenoy ran through a red light at the intersection while traveling at approximately 80 mph in a 40 mph zone when he crashed into Mastropolo’s vehicle. The impact sent Mastropolo’s car flying 65 feet into a box truck, according to Nassau District Attorney Anne Donnelly. Mastropolo died at the scene from his injuries.
Following the fatal crash, Shenoy was not immediately arrested as investigators were still conducting their investigation, Donnelly explained. Instead, Shenoy was taken to a hospital but checked himself out against medical advice. Despite having his passport confiscated by authorities, prosecutors say Shenoy managed to board a plane and flee back to India before he could be formally charged.
“He went to the hospital and against medical advice checked himself out,” Donnelly said during the sentencing proceedings. The Nassau County District Attorney’s Office attempted to have Shenoy arrested in India, but he made bail and successfully eluded authorities for nearly two decades. It wasn’t until 2025 that U.S. Marshals were finally able to bring him back to Nassau County to face charges for the deadly crash.
“It took a long time to get here, but we never gave up,” Donnelly told the court Friday. The case represents one of the longest pursuits of justice in Nassau County’s recent history, spanning two decades and involving international cooperation to bring the defendant back to face charges.
During the emotional sentencing hearing, Mastropolo’s daughter Krystina Marrone, who was just 16 years old when her father was killed, delivered a powerful victim impact statement directly addressing Shenoy. “He wasn’t there on my wedding day. He wasn’t there for the birth of his two grandchildren. You killed a great man, one that lived his life with integrity, dignity and respect, all qualities we wish you would have possessed years ago,” Marrone said in court.
Marrone also spoke about the lasting impact of losing her father, telling the court: “We were left with grief that doesn’t expire in an absence that can never be filled.” Her statement highlighted how Shenoy’s actions robbed her father of experiencing major family milestones and left a permanent void in their lives.
In stark contrast to the family’s emotional testimony, Shenoy showed little remorse during the proceedings. Court observers noted that he smiled at the judge at various points during the hearing. When given the opportunity to address the court, Shenoy made only a brief statement: “Sorry to the family that’s all I can say, thank you.”
District Attorney Donnelly expressed frustration with Shenoy’s decades of freedom while the Mastropolo family suffered. “It’s sad that the family is going through this loss for 20 years and he’s living his best life in India free to come and go,” she said. The sentence of 3.5-10 years in prison was part of a plea agreement that Shenoy accepted after being extradited back to the United States.
Location & Road Context
The fatal crash occurred at the intersection of Levittown Parkway and Old Country Road in Hicksville, a busy commercial corridor in Nassau County. This intersection handles significant traffic volume as Old Country Road serves as a major east-west artery through Nassau County, connecting multiple communities and business districts. Levittown Parkway runs north-south through the heart of one of Long Island’s most densely populated suburban areas, making this intersection a critical junction for local and regional traffic flow.
The crash site is located in a heavily developed area with numerous businesses, shopping centers, and residential neighborhoods nearby. The 40 mph speed limit reflects the mixed-use nature of the corridor, which requires drivers to navigate around pedestrians, turning vehicles, and frequent traffic signals.
Investigation & Legal Proceedings
The complex international investigation began immediately after the April 2005 crash but was complicated by Shenoy’s flight to India. Nassau County prosecutors worked with federal authorities and international law enforcement agencies to track Shenoy’s whereabouts and begin extradition proceedings. The case required cooperation between the Nassau County District Attorney’s Office, U.S. Marshals Service, and Indian authorities.
After Shenoy made bail in India and disappeared for nearly 20 years, the U.S. Marshals Service eventually located him and successfully brought him back to Nassau County in 2025. Upon his return, Shenoy entered into plea negotiations that resulted in the 3.5-10 year prison sentence he received Friday. The plea agreement likely helped avoid a lengthy trial that would have required the victim’s family to relive the tragedy in detail while providing some measure of closure after two decades of waiting for justice.
Broader Impact
This case represents one of Nassau County’s longest-running fugitive investigations and demonstrates the challenges prosecutors face when defendants flee to countries without extradition treaties or where legal proceedings can be prolonged. The 20-year delay in justice highlights how hit-and-run crashes involving fatalities can devastate families not only through the immediate loss of life, but through years of uncertainty about whether the responsible party will ever be held accountable for their actions.