Incident location, Long Island
What Happened
Diana Kutateladze, a 36-year-old Oceanside woman, caused a fatal six-vehicle crash on the Southern State Parkway Sunday night that killed an elderly Westbury couple after she told police she drank whiskey before driving and ended up traveling west in the eastbound lanes, according to prosecutors. Donald Maxwell, 82, and his wife Liscent Barbara Maxwell, 88, were passengers in a 2016 Toyota Highlander when they died in the head-on collision with Kutateladze’s vehicle.
State police said the multi-vehicle crash involved 10 people total, including the Maxwells, Kutateladze, and her husband, who was critically injured in the collision. Prosecutors said Kutateladze was driving a 2020 Cadillac Escalade at 70 mph in the westbound lanes of the parkway when she sideswiped another vehicle west of Exit 17S, near Malverne. Her Escalade then spun out and launched over a metal guardrail into the eastbound lanes, where she crashed head-on into the Highlander carrying the Maxwells.
Kutateladze told police she drank a whiskey and Coke with her husband before driving, according to prosecutors. During a preliminary breath test, she recorded a 0.10% blood alcohol content, exceeding the legal limit of 0.08% for driving, prosecutors said. When police arrived at the scene, officers reported that Kutateladze had glassy eyes and the smell of alcohol on her breath.
The crash left the driver of the Highlander with a broken arm and pelvis, while Kutateladze’s husband, who was riding in the front passenger seat of the Escalade, was left intubated in the hospital with severe injuries including a brain bleed, a cervical spinal fracture, broken ribs, and two fractured femurs, prosecutors said. “Aside from the fatal head-on collision, this defendant’s reckless driving caused even further collisions and destruction on the Southern State Parkway,” Nassau Assistant District Attorney James Taglienti said.
Kutateladze appeared in a Hempstead courtroom Tuesday in a hospital gown and wheelchair for her arraignment, where she was charged with 10 counts, including eight felonies. The charges include aggravated vehicular homicide and two counts of vehicular manslaughter in connection with the deaths of the Maxwells. She pleaded not guilty to all charges and was ordered remanded without bail. Prior to the court appearance, she had been hospitalized Monday at Mount Sinai South Nassau in Oceanside.
“There are witnesses to the defendant’s intoxication, and she admitted to it,” Taglienti said during the court proceedings. “Also, due to the nature of the crash itself, it shows how reckless her driving was to end up on the wrong side of the parkway and crash head on into another vehicle.” Prosecutors asked Kutateladze to surrender her passport, noting she was born in Russia, though her court-appointed Legal Aid defense attorney said she has been a U.S. citizen for several decades.
Location & Road Context
The fatal collision occurred on the Southern State Parkway near Exit 17S in the Malverne area, a busy stretch of the major east-west highway that serves as a critical transportation artery across Long Island. This section of the parkway has been the site of 131 recorded incidents in traffic databases, with recent activity including multiple roadwork projects and overnight crack sealing operations that have impacted traffic flow in the area.
The parkway’s design in this section includes metal guardrails separating the eastbound and westbound lanes, which Kutateladze’s Escalade was able to launch over after spinning out from the initial sideswipe collision, according to prosecutors’ description of the crash sequence.
Investigation & Legal Proceedings
A large group of Maxwell family members attended Tuesday’s arraignment but did not speak to reporters after the proceedings. The case is currently awaiting grand jury action, and Kutateladze appeared at Nassau Criminal Court Wednesday in Mineola for a conference on her case, where she was transported while still recovering from her injuries sustained in the crash.
Kutateladze’s defense attorney provided background about her client during the court proceedings, noting that she has lived in Oceanside for six years and is the mother of four children, including 6-year-old twin boys, a 4-year-old daughter, and a 1-year-old. The attorney said Kutateladze received her Juris Doctor degree from Cardozo Law School last year and has worked as a paralegal for about 16 years, including doing pro bono work for several years at an immigration clinic. The defense emphasized that she has no prior criminal record and has close ties to the community, taking her children to school and a Jewish community center daily. If convicted on the charges, Kutateladze could face between 8 and 25 years in prison.
Broader Impact
The victims, Donald and Liscent Maxwell, were active leaders in the Pentecostal City Mission Church in Far Rockaway, with Liscent Maxwell having previously served as a chaplain for Episcopal Health Services in Far Rockaway. “A chaplain’s chaplain, she was compassionate, caring and exceptional. Her gentle presence brought comfort to many, and her legacy of faithful service endures,” Episcopal Health Pastor Asnel Valcin said in a statement about Liscent Maxwell’s community contributions. The case highlights the severe penalties under New York law for aggravated vehicular homicide, particularly when alcohol is involved and multiple fatalities occur, with potential sentences reaching up to 25 years for the most serious charges.