$3.59 Cheapest
$3.88 Average
116 Stations
1
BJ's
BJ's
841 Old Country RdRiverhead, NY
2
OK
OK Petroleum
1212 E Main StRiverhead, NY
$3.59
M: $4.39 P: $4.49 D: $5.97
per gal 3
BJ's
BJ's
2 Veterans Memorial HwyCommack, NY
$3.61
P: $4.39 D: $5.97
per gal 4
Costco
Costco
10 Garet PlCommack, NY
5
Sinclair
Sinclair
401 Medford AvePatchogue, NY
6
Sunoco
Sunoco
320 Middle Country RdSmithtown, NY
$3.64
M: $4.44 P: $4.74 D: $6.14
per gal 7
Valero
Valero
226 Islip AveIslip, NY
8
Sinclair
Sinclair
645 Main StBay Shore, NY
$3.67
M: $4.07 P: $4.43
per gal 9
Mobil
Mobil
629 Broadhollow RdMelville, NY
$3.67
M: $3.97 P: $4.47 D: $6.29
per gal 10
Mobil
Mobil
1575 Old Country RdRiverhead, NY
$3.67
M: $3.99 P: $4.49 D: $6.37
per gal 11
USA
USA Gas
1171 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY
12
Valero
Valero
2307 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$3.69
P: $4.51 D: $6.29
per gal 13
Mobil
Mobil
113 Medford AvePatchogue, NY
$3.69
P: $4.89 D: $6.29
per gal 14
Mobil
Mobil
770 Montauk HwyPatchogue, NY
$3.69
M: $4.25 P: $4.65 D: $6.29
per gal 15
OK
OK Petroleum
255 E Main StPatchogue, NY
$3.69
M: $4.09 P: $4.49 D: $5.89
per gal 16
Shell
Shell
494 Medford AvePatchogue, NY
$3.69
M: $4.25 P: $4.65 D: $6.09
per gal 17
Speedway
Speedway
214 Islip AveIslip, NY
18
Valero
Valero
455 Waverly AveNorth Patchogue, NY
$3.71
M: $4.47 P: $4.87 D: $6.31
per gal 19
BP
BP
6077 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.79 P: $4.99
per gal 20
Gulf
Bolla Market
2088 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.11 P: $4.61 D: $6.07
per gal 21
Conoco
Commack Fuel
100 Crooked Hill RdCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.27 P: $4.47 D: $6.59
per gal 22
Speedway
Speedway
1173 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.21 P: $4.61 D: $6.25
per gal 23
Speedway
Speedway
2104 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.21 P: $4.61 D: $6.25
per gal 24
Sunoco
Sunoco
2211 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.71
M: $4.11 P: $4.57 D: $6.37
per gal 25
CITGO
CITGO
234 Medford AvePatchogue, NY
$3.73
M: $4.29 P: $4.69 D: $5.99
per gal 26
76
76
989 Sunrise HwyBay Shore, NY
$3.75
M: $4.89 P: $4.99 D: $6.19
per gal 27
Speedway
Speedway
327 E Main StBay Shore, NY
$3.75
M: $4.29 P: $4.75 D: $6.39
per gal 28
Sunoco
Sunoco
343 E Main StPatchogue, NY
$3.75
M: $4.39 P: $5.29 D: $6.29
per gal 29
QuickChek
QuickChek
6233 Jericho TrnpkCommack, NY
$3.75
M: $4.15 P: $4.55 D: $5.99
per gal 30
BP
BP
1075 PARK AVEHuntington, NY
$3.75
M: $4.75 P: $4.85 D: $6.25
per gal 31
7-Eleven
7-Eleven
2320 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$3.75
M: $4.35 P: $4.75 D: $6.29
per gal 32
Mobil
Mobil
2300 Sunrise Hwy Service Rd EastIslip, NY
$3.75
M: $4.15 P: $4.55 D: $6.29
per gal 33
Mobil
Mobil
504 NY-111Hauppauge, NY
$3.75
M: $4.35 P: $4.75 D: $5.99
per gal 34
Speedway
Speedway
522 Smithtown BypassHauppauge, NY
$3.75
M: $4.25 P: $4.75 D: $6.29
per gal 35
7-Eleven
7-Eleven
648 Commack RdCommack, NY
$3.76
M: $4.26 P: $4.66 D: $6.29
per gal 36
7-Eleven
7-Eleven
870 Old Country RdRiverhead, NY
$3.76
M: $4.26 P: $4.66 D: $6.47
per gal 37
BP
Gas Sale
303 Maple AveSmithtown, NY
$3.77
M: $4.47 P: $4.77 D: $5.89
per gal 38
Exxon
US Petroleum
323 Middle Country RdSmithtown, NY
$3.77
M: $4.47 P: $4.77 D: $5.97
per gal 39
Mobil
Mobil
1050 Udall RdBay Shore, NY
$3.79
M: $4.29 P: $4.69 D: $6.35
per gal 40
Mobil
Mobil
236 Bay Shore RdBay Shore, NY
$3.79
M: $4.71 P: $5.09 D: $6.29
per gal 41
Valero
Valero
1692 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
42
CITGO
CITGO
621 Commack RdCommack, NY
$3.79
P: $4.89 D: $6.29
per gal 43
Mobil
Mobil
5087 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$3.79
M: $4.19 P: $4.69 D: $6.29
per gal 44
Petrol
Petrol USA
230 Commack RdCommack, NY
45
Sunoco
Sunoco
90 Vanderbilt Motor PkwyCommack, NY
$3.79
M: $4.79 P: $4.79 D: $6.15
per gal 46
Shell
Shell
9 Lake AveRiverhead, NY
47
Shell
Shell
626 W Main StRiverhead, NY
$3.79
M: $4.89 P: $5.19 D: $6.29
per gal 48
BP
BP
240 W MAIN STSmithtown, NY
$3.79
M: $4.19 P: $4.59
per gal 49
Mobil
Mobil
819 West Jericho TpkeSmithtown, NY
$3.79
M: $4.35 P: $4.75 D: $6.29
per gal 50
USA
USA
95 Moffitt BlvdBay Shore, NY
51
Shell
Shell
267 E Main StPatchogue, NY
$3.85
M: $4.59 P: $4.89 D: $5.99
per gal 52
Conoco
Conoco
1905 Jericho TpkeEast Northport, NY
$3.85
M: $4.33 P: $4.73 D: $6.19
per gal 53
Sunoco
Sunoco
540 Islip AveIslip, NY
$3.85
M: $4.05 P: $4.69
per gal 54
Mobil
Ultra Mart
278 W Main StSmithtown, NY
$3.85
M: $4.35 P: $4.85 D: $6.33
per gal 55
BP
BP
1007 W JERICHO TPKESmithtown, NY
$3.86
M: $4.52 P: $4.92 D: $6.44
per gal 56
Exxon
Exxon
172 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
$3.87
M: $4.49 P: $4.89
per gal 57
Shell
Shell
168 Howells RdBay Shore, NY
58
7-Eleven
7-Eleven
1733 Old Country RdRiverhead, NY
59
BP
BP
1320 5TH AVEBay Shore, NY
60
BP
BP
1672 5TH AVEBay Shore, NY
$3.89
M: $4.45 P: $4.75 D: $6.27
per gal 61
BP
BP
1490 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$3.89
M: $4.39 P: $4.79 D: $6.19
per gal 62
Mobil
Mobil
211 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$3.89
P: $4.69 D: $6.29
per gal 63
Shell
Shell
1701 Union BlvdBay Shore, NY
$3.89
M: $4.89 P: $5.15
per gal 64
CITGO
Sunoco
1310 5th AveBay Shore, NY
65
Mobil
Mobil
451 W Main StPatchogue, NY
66
Shell
Shell
700 Commack RdCommack, NY
$3.89
M: $4.59 P: $4.99 D: $6.49
per gal 67
Shell
Shell
170 Veterans Memorial HwyCommack, NY
68
BP
BP
341 W Jericho TpkeHuntington, NY
$3.89
P: $5.49 D: $6.19
per gal 69
Island
Island Gas
405 New York AveHuntington, NY
$3.89
M: $4.69 P: $4.99 D: $6.25
per gal 70
Ultra
Ultra
128 Main StHuntington, NY
71
Conoco
Conoco
475 Walt Whitman RdMelville, NY
$3.89
M: $4.79 P: $5.14 D: $5.99
per gal 72
76
76
7 Peconic AveRiverhead, NY
73
Empire
Empire
1050 Osborne AveRiverhead, NY
74
Mobil
Mobil
415 E Main StRiverhead, NY
75
Sunoco
Sunoco
1879 Old Country Rd 58Riverhead, NY
$3.89
M: $4.89 D: $6.39
per gal 76
BP
BP
762 SMITHTOWN BYPSmithtown, NY
$3.89
M: $4.45 P: $4.85 D: $6.49
per gal 77
Shell
Shell
560 Middle Country RdSaint James, NY
$3.89
M: $4.35 P: $4.75 D: $6.49
per gal 78
Shell
Shell
279 W Main StPatchogue, NY
$3.91
M: $4.49 P: $4.89
per gal 79
Exxon
Exxon
1501 5th AveBay Shore, NY
80
BP
BP
195 Pine Aire DrBay Shore, NY
81
Mobil
Mobil
221 W Main StBay Shore, NY
$3.95
M: $4.59 P: $4.69 D: $6.19
per gal 82
Shell
Shell
1365 Montauk HwyEast Patchogue, NY
83
76
76
15 Veterans Memorial HwyCommack, NY
$3.95
M: $4.45 P: $4.85
per gal 84
Shell
Shell
1010 Walt Whitman RdMelville, NY
$3.95
M: $4.79 P: $5.19 D: $6.19
per gal 85
Valero
Valero
151 Hospital RdEast Patchogue, NY
86
Gulf
Gulf
253 BroadwayHuntington, NY
87
USA
USA
211 Broadway-Greenlawn RdHuntington, NY
88
Shell
Shell
1508 5th AveBay Shore, NY
$3.99
M: $4.69 P: $5.09 D: $6.39
per gal 89
Ultimate
Ultimate
270 W Main StPatchogue, NY
90
Valero
Valero
626 Medford AvePatchogue, NY
91
Shell
Shell
444 Commack RdCommack, NY
$3.99
M: $4.95 P: $5.25 D: $6.45
per gal 92
BP
BP
743 WALT WHITMAN RDMelville, NY
$3.99
M: $4.89 P: $5.29
per gal 93
Valero
Valero
1356 OLD COUNTRY RDRiverhead, NY
94
Ultra
Ultra
231 W Jericho TpkeSmithtown, NY
$3.99
M: $4.49 P: $4.89 D: $6.39
per gal 95
BP
BP
464 W JERICHO TPKEHuntington, NY
$4.03
M: $5.29 P: $5.49 D: $6.29
per gal 96
BP
BP
209 TERRY RDSmithtown, NY
97
Conoco
Conoco
234 Wall StHuntington, NY
$4.07
M: $4.65 P: $4.85
per gal 98
Shell
Shell
515 E Main StBay Shore, NY
$4.09
M: $4.69 P: $5.19
per gal 99
Sunoco
Automotive Technologies
116 Spring RdHuntington, NY
100
Sunoco
Sunoco
160 New York AveHuntington, NY
101
Valero
Valero
445 W Jericho TpkeHuntington, NY
$4.09
M: $4.69 P: $4.89 D: $6.15
per gal 102
Husco
Husco
736 Main StIslip, NY
$4.09
M: $4.79 P: $5.29
per gal 103
Phillips 66
Southdown Encore Station
235 Wall StHuntington, NY
$4.11
M: $4.71 P: $4.91
per gal 104
BP
BP
156 W MAIN STBabylon, NY
$4.13
M: $4.85 P: $5.37
per gal 105
Conoco
Conoco
132 E Main StHuntington, NY
106
CITGO
CITGO
2039 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$4.19
M: $4.95 P: $5.45 D: $6.35
per gal 107
Sunoco
Spiffy Car Wash & Gas
1103 Jericho TpkeCommack, NY
$4.19
M: $4.95 P: $5.45 D: $6.35
per gal 108
Mobil
Mobil
472 West Jericho TpkeHuntington, NY
109
Shell
Shell
161 New York AveHuntington, NY
$4.19
P: $5.19 D: $6.59
per gal 110
CITGO
CITGO
1153 Walt Whitman RdMelville, NY
$4.19
M: $4.67 P: $5.25 D: $6.89
per gal 111
CITGO
CITGO
1429 Main RdJamesport, NY
112
Conoco
Conoco
728 Walt Whitman RdMelville, NY
$4.24
M: $4.73 P: $5.13 D: $6.73
per gal 113
Gulf
Gulf
532 Walt Whitman RdMelville, NY
$4.24
M: $5.22 P: $5.24 D: $6.64
per gal 114
Exxon
Exxon
570 Sunrise HwyWest Islip, NY
$4.35
M: $4.49 P: $4.89 D: $6.29
per gal 115
Sunoco
Sunoco
114 Broadhollow RdMelville, NY
116
Valero
US 1
1164 Montauk HwyEast Patchogue, NY
—
P: $4.79 D: $6.35
per gal